What's the zoning on 123 Main Street, and what can I do with it?
R-2 — single- and two-family residential. The existing structure is legal-conforming. A duplex conversion is use-by-right; adding square footage requires a variance.
- Side setbacks5 ft
- Front setback30 ft
- Rear setback5 ft
- Max FAR0.55
The lot sits at the coverage ceiling — 1,750 sqft of structure on a 5,000 sqft lot is 35% coverage, right at the 35% R-2 cap. You can't add new living space without losing some of the existing footprint, but the existing structure is grandfathered and you can convert the upper level to a separate legal unit (use-by-right under R-2).
Belmar passed a 2024 short-term-rental ordinance capping new STR permits. Existing rental history carries forward, but a new rental conversion on this parcel would need a permit from a closed pool — assume owner-occupied or long-term-rental unless prior STR records exist.
Parcel-level setback diagram, historical-district overlay, and STR-permit lookup are in Scout.